Hank Rearden in the Pews

Why the producer was told he was guilty, and why Christ, not Rand, sets him free.

The man at the mill

In Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged, Hank Rearden runs a steel company he built from nothing. After ten years of work he produces a new metal, stronger and lighter than steel. It will carry railroads, bridges and an economy. Thousands of families eat because his mills run.

And almost everyone around him treats him as a villain. His family lives off his money and despises him for having it. The press calls him greedy. The government calls his success a danger to the public. Worst of all, for most of the story Rearden half believes them. He carries a quiet guilt he cannot name, for the crime of being good at what he does.

Rearden is fiction. The guilt is not.

The accusation in the pews

Many producers have heard a version of that accusation in church. Rarely is it stated outright. It comes as an implication repeated until it feels like doctrine:

So the founder sits in the back row and wonders whether God can love someone like him. The engineer stops mentioning his work. The woman who built a business from her kitchen table feels she must apologize for it. Many of them eventually conclude that there is no place for them in Christ, and they leave.

That conclusion is false, and Christian Egoism exists to say so.

Rand's answer

Rand saw the problem clearly. At the turning point of the novel, Rearden realizes the guilt only worked because he agreed to it. Rand calls this the sanction of the victim: the producer's enemies need his consent to their judgment of him. Once Rearden refuses that consent, their power over him breaks.

Rand's remedy was to reject the false judgment at its root. For her there is no God above the individual, no judge whose verdict outranks a man's own honest reckoning. The self is the standard.

On the diagnosis, Rand was right. False guilt is a weapon, and it works only on those who accept it. And to be fair to her, Rand's system does recognize real guilt: she distinguished earned guilt from unearned guilt, and she held the producer to account for the first. But her answer to earned guilt is self-correction, and self-correction is all her system can offer. A man with no judge above him also has no one to forgive him. Rand has no grace. And every honest producer knows he has done things that need forgiving.

Two kinds of guilt

Christianity distinguishes what Rand's system cannot resolve: real guilt and false guilt.

Real guilt is for sin. Lying to a customer, cheating a partner, neglecting your family for your work, treating people as tools. Every one of us carries it, the producer and the critic alike. "All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" (Romans 3:23).

False guilt is for things that are not sin: building, producing, earning, providing, excelling. It is the guilt the producer was handed in the pews, and it has no basis in the words of Jesus.

Rand's remedy for real guilt is to correct yourself and move on. Christ's remedy is forgiveness, and that is the better way.

Christ's answer

For real guilt, Christ does not deny the judgment. He takes it. "He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree" (1 Peter 2:24). The debt is not cancelled by pretending it does not exist. It is paid in full, by Him.

For false guilt, Christ simply never imposes it. Look at whom He called.

Matthew sat at a tax booth, a man of money and the counting table, despised by everyone who passed. Jesus did not lecture him. He said two words, "Follow me," and then went to dinner at his house with his friends (Matthew 9:9–13). When the religious leaders objected, Jesus answered that He came for exactly people like these.

Zacchaeus was a chief tax collector and rich. Jesus called him down from a tree by name and invited himself over (Luke 19:1–10). Zacchaeus repented, and notice what he repented of: he promised to repay fourfold anyone he had defrauded. He repented of fraud, his real guilt. He was not told to repent of being productive.

The pattern is consistent. Jesus calls the producer to account for sin. He never calls him to account for producing.

No condemnation

"There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus." Romans 8:1

This is the verse for every Hank Rearden in the pews. Rand's producer refuses the sanction of his accusers because he answers to no one. The Christian producer refuses it for a stronger reason: he answers to Someone, and that Someone has already ruled. The only judge whose verdict matters has declared him free.

That freedom is not permission. A man forgiven for cheating does not go back to cheating; Zacchaeus paid back fourfold. But a man forgiven is no longer for sale to anyone else's guilt. No one can make him ashamed of the mill.

What this means for you

If you are a producer who was told there was no place for you in Christ, here is the truth:

  1. Bring your real guilt to Christ. He already paid for it. Confess it and be free of it.
  2. Refuse the false guilt. Building, earning and providing are not sins. No pastor, critic or family member has the authority to make them sins.
  3. Return to the work, and give the glory to God. You bear the image of a Creator. The talents in your hands were entrusted to you. Use them.

Rearden needed hundreds of pages to understand that his guilt had no claim on him. You need only four words, and Jesus already said them — the same words He spoke to a forgiven woman: "Your sins are forgiven" (Luke 7:48).

Then go build.

I am the man who loves the life God gave me. I will not bury my gifts, and I will not surrender my values to anyone's false guilt. The sacrifice that saves me was already made. The sacrifices He asks of me, I make freely. And the One who saves me is my foundation.

← Back to Essays